What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Key West, Florida for the first time?
Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Key West
Showing:
61 - 90 of 262 answers
61 - 90 of 262 answers
Troy Tolliver
Definitely find out what the water temperature is to evaluate. What kind of fish you’re gonna go for in the time length.
Michael Slentz
This was our first time fishing in Key West, if you want to learn how to fish, these are the guys to teach you!
Piper Hughes
Orlando, Florida
Get out there! Great fishing Reef, Deep Sea and Backwater. Been a few times all good great fishing community.
Mary K Derby
Sure this is a safe first trip in the keys. The four hour trip is just long enough to catch dinner and still learn bout open water fishing
Aaron Lutgring
Tell City, IN
The sun and heat are brutal. You may think you want to wear short sleeves and shorts but don’t. Long breathable pants and a breathable shirt would be best.
Tim Woods
Thorold, ON
Inquire to what fish are in season and what fish you will be after as it depends on how long of a trip you book.
Sean Williams
Mesa, AZ
Check with an experienced Captain and take their advice on when to schedule your next fishing trip to the area. Try to come at the peak fishing times.
Shannon Mattos
Fordsville, KY
It was well worth it! We had a blast for our first deep sea fishing experience. Would definitely do it again.
Niki Parris
Loudon, TN
Get a good captain who knows the water & loves what he does! The not only know how to find the fish, but coach and ensure you have a great time while doing it!
Ben Bell
Shrewsbury, MA
Do it. Was an absolute blast. Fresh home made fish tacos with the mahi were the best I have ever had!
Jeff Hurst
Arlington, TX
#1...Fish with My Ohana.
#2...Bring your muscles. There will be allot of reeling.
#3...Bring sunscreen, the sun will find you.
Mark Nottingham
Lutz, FL
I would recommend starting off with a 2 hour fishing charter and then moving up from there. Next time we will be ready for a half day of fishing in Key West.
Rodney Fowler
Plenty of water. Wear hats . Use sunscreen. Check on size of boat before you book . Morning is best if you can’t handle the heat of sun .
Joseph Danese
Minneapolis, Minnesota
I recommend using reel easy charters for first timers. We have been coming down for years and had a hard time finding good captains. Not the case with reel easy charters.
John Biddy
We had a great experience, but it was our first trip during the summer months, so I would do your research/homework before booking a trip.
Julie Fernandez
North Wales, PA
Shop around and ask questions to the charter you are interested in. Ask about the type of fish they plan on going out for and how far.
Don't be afraid to ask questions.
Jeff Curtis
Take a charter and enjoy the day. They will handle getting you to a good spot to catch. Take your fresh catch to a local restaurant and have them cook it. Ours was excellent!
Richard Mauk
Greenbackville, VA
Don’t cut yourself short on time. Our fishing trip was amazing. The waters around here are beautiful and for the most part extremely calm. Definitely a trip we will take again!
Christine Hutchinson
Stuart, Florida
Know the fish are there but sometimes not biting. That’s way it’s called fishing not catching. Know Captain Dave is trying everything to get you fish
John Johnson
Scituate, Massachusetts
Check the charters for what you want to do. There are many very experienced captains and crews waiting to make your day.
Ben Lydell
Wilder, ID
End of the year for a bit cooler weather, a little breeze definitely helped keep cool. Lots of water and sunscreen applied
David Campbell
Make sure to bring a hat, sun glasses and some water/Gatorade. Consider motion sickness pills if you have never been out on the water. Bring sun screen. Relax, have fun and enjoy your experience!
Judith Adirzone
You are in good hands with the Capt. and Mate on the Corsair II. They were awesome and made the entire experience enjoyable.
James Lippert
Rossford, OH
Do a half day and get to understand the ropes. Then if you get what you expect go do more. Just do it!
Jeff Macknik
Shinglehouse, PA
April is a great time to go fish Key West. Message your captain. They know how to cater to your wants and needs
Ken Fuller
Ashburn, Virginia
Mahi Mahi is one of the most beautiful fish to catch and incredibly great eating!! Look up Capt. Anthony Del Valle of the Sea Rebel. Great down to earth, knowledgeable captain!!
John Conrad
Tangier, IN
Always get a captain that is very knowledgeable with the fishing conditions and puts the clients first.
Michael Holder
Blauvelt, NY
I recommend confirming your boat directly, because when using Fishing Booker, I was pawned off to another vessel the night before.
Paul Garfinkel
Westwood, NJ
Be prepared for high winds - let you captain know if you prefer flatter water or are good with some rollers.
Cody Hislop
Virginia Beach, VA
See what the bite is like and if the weather isn’t great get a charter with someone who can bring you to the shallower sections to have a better shot at some fish.