What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Key West, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Key West

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
91 - 120 of 273 answers
customer-avatar
Ben Lydell
Wilder, ID
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with My Ohana Sport Fishing on Mayo 18, 2023
End of the year for a bit cooler weather, a little breeze definitely helped keep cool. Lots of water and sunscreen applied

customer-avatar
David Campbell
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Jolly Roger II on Mayo 15, 2023
Make sure to bring a hat, sun glasses and some water/Gatorade. Consider motion sickness pills if you have never been out on the water. Bring sun screen. Relax, have fun and enjoy your experience!

customer-avatar
Judith Adirzone
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Corsair 2 Sportfishing Key West on Mayo 5, 2023
You are in good hands with the Capt. and Mate on the Corsair II. They were awesome and made the entire experience enjoyable.

customer-avatar
James Lippert
Rossford, OH
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Reel Smoker on Mayo 3, 2023
Do a half day and get to understand the ropes. Then if you get what you expect go do more. Just do it!

customer-avatar
Jeff Macknik
Shinglehouse, PA
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Easy Does It on Abril 27, 2023
April is a great time to go fish Key West. Message your captain. They know how to cater to your wants and needs

customer-avatar
Ken Fuller
Ashburn, Virginia
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Maritime Co. – Sea Rebel on Abril 21, 2023
Mahi Mahi is one of the most beautiful fish to catch and incredibly great eating!! Look up Capt. Anthony Del Valle of the Sea Rebel. Great down to earth, knowledgeable captain!!

customer-avatar
John Conrad
Tangier, IN
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Boa Vida Charters 1 on Abril 17, 2023
Always get a captain that is very knowledgeable with the fishing conditions and puts the clients first.

customer-avatar
Michael Holder
Blauvelt, NY
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Fish Key West – The Coolwater II on Abril 3, 2023
I recommend confirming your boat directly, because when using Fishing Booker, I was pawned off to another vessel the night before.

customer-avatar
Paul Garfinkel
Westwood, NJ
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Boa Vida Charters – Jazmine on Abril 5, 2023
Be prepared for high winds - let you captain know if you prefer flatter water or are good with some rollers.

customer-avatar
Cody Hislop
Virginia Beach, VA
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with My Ohana Sport Fishing on Marzo 16, 2023
See what the bite is like and if the weather isn’t great get a charter with someone who can bring you to the shallower sections to have a better shot at some fish.

customer-avatar
William Dugdale
Fishers, IN
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Sea-Clusion Charter Boat on Marzo 18, 2023
Spring for a bigger boat with more amenities like AC in a closed in cabin, a head, and a captain's chair.

customer-avatar
Les Wills
Portland, OR
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Capt Conch Charters- Reef Runner II on Marzo 13, 2023
Be sure to specify what you would like to catch and choose a charter wisely or you will be less likely to enjoy the experience.

customer-avatar
Melissa Peterson
Circle Pines, MN
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Outta Line Charters on Febrero 25, 2023
Go out of the main docks in Key West. They seemed to catch more fish than we did on the same day of fishing

customer-avatar
Scott Brotnov
Evergreen, MT
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Cowboy Charters – Cowboy Since 1965 on Marzo 10, 2023
If you want mahi or tuna wait till may. If you dint care what you catch and just went to have fun, go anytime

customer-avatar
Margie Mayberry
Littleton, CO
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Jolly Roger II on Noviembre 17, 2022
Bring over the counter motion sickness medicine, even if you don’t get motion sickness. We caught fish in the afternoon, but we heard the morning is the best time to fish.

customer-avatar
Alison Centerbar
Lake Worth, FL
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Cora Beth Fishing on Mayo 29, 2022
I’d highly recommend going with an experienced crew like the Cora Beth. They know exactly where to go and what to do to guarantee you catch fish!

customer-avatar
Robert Marcus
St. Petersburg, Florida
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters 33' on Mayo 19, 2022
Check the fishing reports and be flexible. Fishing is usually good but you need a Capt that can adjust to the conditions

customer-avatar
Justin VanZandt
Sand Springs, OK
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Capt. Conch Charters - Conch Too on Mayo 13, 2022
I would recommend waiting til after May to fish or to make sure the weather is good and the water is warmer, makes for better fishing.

customer-avatar
Robert Buzby
Woodbury, NJ
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Capt. Conch Charters - Conch Too on Diciembre 6, 2021
Don't be discouraged if you don't catch any fish. ? Sometimes they are biting sometimes they're not.

customer-avatar
JOHN SPEES
Simpsonville, SC
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Good Times Key West on Diciembre 2, 2021
We had a great experience. We were not after trophy fish. We just wanted to have fun & we definitely did. Afterwards we went to a recommended restaurant where they cooked up our catch.

customer-avatar
Brandon Streu
Britton, MI
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Fish Key West - The Coolcast on Octubre 26, 2021
Know what you want to fish. I have never fished the ocean, just the Great Lakes and wanted a real fight. Do you want quantity, or a quality fight? Know that going into your trip.

customer-avatar
Angel Strohm
Thompsontown, PA
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Reel Easy Charters on Septiembre 26, 2021
It was very hot! Stick with half days or at the most eight hours. We had scheduled extended day and am glad the Captain talked us out of it!

customer-avatar
Mary Brewer
Granite Quarry, NC
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Fish Key West - The Coolcast on Julio 21, 2021
Recommend 1/2 day trips. John our captain was great..very knowledgeable. Will do this again next time we're here. Thanks!

customer-avatar
Dennis Hasson
Marathon, Florida
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Reel Easy Charters on Febrero 10, 2021
Captain Chris was awesome! Best guided trip we have ever taken! Reel Easy charters is absolutely our choice next time we head down!!! Thanks again!! Dennis Hasson

customer-avatar
Richard Frizelis
Chicago, IL
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Good Times Key West on Diciembre 13, 2020
We did a snorkel and sightseeing trip with this charter and they did the most amazing trip for us could not have asked for a better trip.

customer-avatar
Angela Sustello
San Juan
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Corsair 2 Sportfishing Key West on Octubre 18, 2020
Apparently because of the NW winds the fishing wasn’t great but I think it was more of a weather thing than a season thing

customer-avatar
Matt Seeber
Key West, FL
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Michael O’Brien Charters on Agosto 11, 2020
Sometimes the fish aren't biting. There are no guarantees. Enjoy the view and the scenery and conversation if nothing else.

customer-avatar
Kate Zemba
Perrysburg, OH
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Good Times Key West on Julio 26, 2020
Sunscreen!!!! Also, have an idea of what type of fishing you’d like to do before booking and heading out, that way your captain can get you to the best spot!

customer-avatar
Kevin Chervenka
Austin, TX
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Corsair 2 Sportfishing Key West on Enero 6, 2020
watch the weather and make sure there are no cold fronts coming through. Only so much the crew can do with the weather.

customer-avatar
Tony Depierro
Boca Raton, Florida
VERIFICADO  
Went fishing with Corsair 2 Sportfishing Key West on Agosto 14, 2019
Book your trip with a Captain who knows the area and Captain Russ has been in the Key West area fishing his entire life.